|
We are kindly asking for
donations to a legal defense fund, set up on our behalf
through our attorney, Richard Jaffe. We
really need donations so that we may continue to push back against the FTC's unfair
and unconstitutional regulations against sellers of dietary supplements. With
your support we honestly believe we can prevail. Please donate to our legal
defense fund - anything at all helps and is greatly appreciated. *
* * * * * * * * * On
September 18th 2008 the FTC held a press conference announcing administrative
cases (lawsuits) against five companies including Native Essence. The cases will
be tried before an administrative law judge at the Commission. Read it here: FTC
Press Release 9-18-08 * * * * * * * * * * On
September 11th 2008 we had a hearing in a Santa Fe court. The judge agreed
with the FTC and the DOJ and dismissed our case against the FTC. The judge decided
since the FTC has yet to take any formal action against Native Essence (just threatened
action), there is no "case or controversy" that permits the federal
courts to invoke jurisdiction. In other words although the FTC threatened to have
a Santa Fe district court appoint a receiver to take over our company and freeze
our assets it argued that we had no right to have a Santa Fe district court hear
our case against them. So our case and our motion for a preliminary injunction
were never heard. *
* * * * * * * * * On
August 26th 2008 we filed a brief opposing the FTC's motion to dismiss.
The brief argues that since we have raised a constitutional challenge to the FTC's
rules forbidding certain types of speech, the courts have jurisdiction to hear
the case. Read it here: Law
in opposition to the FTC's Motion to Dismiss *
* * * * * * * * * On
July 31st 2008 nine FTC and U.S. Department of Justice attorneys filed
a motion to dismiss our case against them. The FTC argues that since it has yet
to take any formal action against Native Essence, there is no "case or controversy"
that permits the federal courts to invoke jurisdiction. Read it here: FTC's
Motion to Dismiss *
* * * * * * * * * On
July 15th 2008 we filed a motion for a preliminary injunction asking the
courts to allow us to post or link to herbal information available at federal
government websites such as the National Center for Complimentary and Alternative
Medicine until this matter is resolved. Read it here: Motion
for a Preliminary Injunction Law
in Support of Preliminary Injunction *
* * * * * * * * * Click
here to see how this all came about Click
here to see a copy of our complaint filed in a New Mexico district court *
* * * * * * * * * Native
Essence Herb Company Sues FTC
TAOS, N.M.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--June 25, 2008--For the first time, the Federal Trade
Commission is being sued over the use of history.
A New Mexico herb company says the First Amendment gives it the right to tell
customers the historical use of herbs in treating serious diseases. The FTC says
this violates its guidelines.
Now the issue is headed to court. Native Essence Herb Company, and its owners
Mark and Marianne Hershiser, has sued to strike down the FTC's guidelines.
The lawsuit was filed by Houston attorney Richard A. Jaffe, Esq., a leading health
care attorney and the author of "Galileo's Lawyer," an insider's look
into the battles between the government and the complementary medicine field.
"Herb sellers should be
able to tell consumers that an herb has a long historical use to treat a disease,"
says Jaffe. "The FTC's prohibition of this kind of truthful information is
unreasonable and unconstitutional."
The lawsuit asks the federal court to declare the FTC's guidelines on "historical
use claims" for herbal remedies a violation of the First Amendment.
Company owner Hershiser wants to post this historical use information on his website,
much of which is taken from federal government websites, and he wants the courts
to allow him that right. "This
is a precedent-setting case," Jaffe says. "The issue has never been
litigated; it not only affects the Hershisers, but all companies which sell herbal
products."
In April 2008, the FTC told the New Mexico herb company that its website contained
false, misleading or unsubstantiated claims, including claims that some of the
listed herbs have been used for hundreds or thousands of years by Native Americans
and other cultures. The FTC received no consumer complaints, yet it threatened
to file an injunction action against the company.
Native Essence removed that information about their products from their website.
However, the company owners decided not to settle with the FTC, but file suit
to overturn the FTC's advertising guidelines and seek a judicial ruling allowing
sellers of herbal remedies to provide consumers with information found on government
websites and other recognized legitimate sources.
CONTACT: Law Offices of Richard A. Jaffe Richard Jaffe, Esq. 713-626-3550
713-857-8096 cell rickjaffeesq@aol.com
back
to the top |